The USD 30 Billion Sale-&-Leaseback of India's Internet Economy (1/2)
India’s internet economy has two choices, an immediate USD 30 Billion Sale-and-Leaseback or a USD 3 Trillion value harvesting over decades, the choice is sadly made. This post has a sequel (2/2).
I wrote this for BusinessWorld, & reposted it here. Sequel (2/2) here . For future India internet essays, subscribe:
Introduction to sale-and-leaseback
In real estate, shipping and, aviation, a sale-and-leaseback involves selling an asset to raise capital upfront, then rent-leasing that very asset back from the purchaser.
India is perhaps the world's first country to inadvertently, sale-and-leaseback its internet economy.
Understanding the Sale
Multiple free-for-user platforms owning, yet mono-product digital advertising giants, Facebook and Google have separately, but equally proudly announced a total of USD 16 Billion in investments tagging India's elected leaders with emotive hashtags like #empoweringIndia, #digitalIndia, in their press and social media announcements.
If we add another USD 14 Billion of Uber, Twitter, LinkedIn, Amazon and other foreign technology company investments that may come in, this ballparks to an eloquent sum of USD 30 billion, the sum at which the internet economy of the world's second-most populous country with the second-largest internet user base has been sold. Indian parents have ensured this investment-attracting-spree goes viral via India's legendary good-morning-forwards WhatsApp engine since they clearly see a hopeful future for their kids being employed with these well-paying digital technology colonizers, not to mention the Instagram worthy swag merchandise for new joiners.
Boston Consulting Group has categorized Indian's everyday internet journey via 8 S’s, seeing (YouTube), Shopping (Amazon), Studying (YouTube), Saving (UPI), Selling (Facebook, WhatsApp, Olx), Socializing (Facebook, Instagram), Searching (Google, Maps), Selecting (Online reviews).
All of these S's are directly or indirectly influenced by Google, Facebook, LinkedIn, Twitter, and other foreign technology companies, which offer their multiple platforms free to users, in exchange for permissions to access user digital footprints and sell high precision targeted digital advertisements.
Understanding the Leaseback
India collectively bought advertising worth INR 11,000 crores (USD 1.6 Billion) on Google and Facebook in 2019, this number grows 25% each year. Do the math.
All Indian businesses, big or small, listed or unlisted, sole proprietorships to mega conglomerates have begun allocating budget to advertisements on Google and Facebook. Legend has it, that the largest benefactor of startup funding in India is, well you guessed it, these twin advertising giants. All startups, be it e-commerce, fintech, EdTech or travel invest a chunky portion of their total capital raised on advertisements in Google and Facebook. Each small business needs a Facebook and Google profile. Your reliable handyman, carpenter, painter, plumber increasingly have their Google profiles.
Nothing wrong, except it’s Indians paying foreign-owned, foreign-listed, digital platforms to make money off digital advertisements shown to Indians. Facebook and Google India operations are generating a constantly growing, mountain-sized high gross margin revenue, most of that revenue gets booked overseas with Indian tax authorities playing catchup.
Investors in these foreign technology companies, listed on the NYSE, continue to see growth from emerging markets, the digital colonies, propelling the stock prices, onwards and upwards. India which is selling its internet economy now pays rent to access its very own internet economy.
The implications for Indians
Take for example, Google Pay, which curiously six-month head started its UPI race, now commands a fifty percent market share of India's free for consumers, over-a-billion transactions per month UPI payment method.
Cashless Consumer’s Srikanth L recently revealed, at 255 million installations, GooglePay is now India’s largest payments app, bigger than Paytm’s 250 million installations. Perhaps Google unfairly pre-burned Google Pay on Android Phones, another rent seeking platform they own.
The advertisements on Google Pay will shortly begin, any Indian financial services companies including digital lenders, banks, investment managers, stockbrokers will be able to target Indian UPI consumers, with massive potential advertising revenue accruing to Google Pay.
Why should this revenue not accrue to our very own, NPCI’s exceptionally efficient BHIM app?
Think of this phenomenon repeating across industries, Indian businesses buying advertisements on foreign platforms, to advertise to Indians.
China’s USD 3 Trillion Vision approach
Compare and contrast this with China, which laid an internet economy vision and built enabling policy provisions for its domestic internet economy to flourish, reflecting in the USD 3 Trillion valuation of listed and unlisted, China headquartered home-grown technology giants such as Tencent (WeChat, video-game PUBG), Alibaba, Alipay, JD, Baidu (China's Google), Meituan Dianping, DiDi (China's Uber), Kuaishou, Byte Dance (TikTok) and EdTech VIP Kid. Most of these companies are global category creators or leaders. Global venture capital funds invest in these companies and many of them have ultimately listed and unlocked their value, in hold your breath, America. China has aced maximizing the potential of its internet economy. China led the world in the manufacturing of physical goods, it is now second to America, in the manufacturing of digital goods and services.
Ironically, nothing validates the importance of China's global technology prowess better than, countries in territorial, economic or COVID pandemic blame-game disputes with China, as an immediate anti-dote have or are warning to block off Chinese tech assets3 operating in their countries, illustrating the size, scale, fear and global importance of China' growing internet economy.
India - The road not taken
Imagine if India replicated the China USD 3 Trillion internet economy vision, we would perhaps miss on the immediate USD 30 Billion potential investments by Google and Facebook, but in a decade build, unlock and harvest value from a potential USD 3 Trillion worth of internet economy. A digital economy so large, that, pun unintended, it would come with a risk of other countries warning to block off Indian internet apps if ever, any territorial or economic disputes arose.
India’s internet economy has two choices, an immediate USD 30 Billion Sale-and-Leaseback or a USD 3 Trillion value harvesting over decades, the choice is sadly, inadvertently made.
Thankfully, India 🇮🇳 has decisive political leadership, which, once it understands the implications, can immediately secure India’s digital future.
I write a 5-point-actionable-agenda to secure India’s internet economy in the second part of this essay, to read click to read the sequel here (2/2)
PS: Bloomberg columnist Andy Mukherjee asked, whether it was possible for India to back to the ‘fork’ in the road now.
Yes, it certainly is:
I write a weekly post on everything +91 🇮🇳 Digital: e-Comm, Fintech, GigEconomy.